Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Religion > Bahai II > Re: Baha'i Excl...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 46 of 50 Topic 2640 of 2741
Post > Topic >>

Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL

by "Susan Maneck" <smaneck@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > May 18, 2008 at 10:42 PM

> I am asking, as clearly as I can, what is the great significance of the
> Covenant if all it means is recognizing the succession?

No one said that *all* it means is recognizing the successor.

>> I have no idea if He expressed those ideas. I was not there.
>
> No idea?  Really?  Do you doubt the approved texts as well?  I mean, you
> weren't there.
>
> Okay, I thought I was talking to someone who knew the Baha'i Faith.

He apparently knows it well enough to know the difference between an
authoritative and non-authoritative text. Something you apparently
don't know.


 Most
> Baha'is I know think He said that,

Which as what do with whether He actually said it?

 and according the the safe-guarded
> successor****p He certainly said things that were similar.

Is the above supposed to mean something?

 I think even
> Susan would say that it is likely He said it.  What about it Susan?

The authority of the Writings is based on what we *know* was written
by the Central Figures not on what we think They likely said.

Susan
 




 50 Posts in Topic:
Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-16 14:33:01 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-16 15:10:33 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-16 14:16:24 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-16 16:06:20 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-16 15:36:54 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-16 17:28:03 
AO as a channel
Douglas McAdam <dougla  2008-05-16 17:41:11 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
tsuki190 <tsuki190@[EM  2008-05-16 14:51:14 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-17 07:39:05 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-16 16:55:22 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
tsuki190 <tsuki190@[EM  2008-05-17 08:38:16 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-17 11:15:55 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-17 11:31:23 
Re: AO as a channel
Sen <sen.sonja@[EMAIL   2008-05-17 09:43:37 
Re: AO as a channel
Douglas McAdam <dougla  2008-05-17 13:27:47 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
diamondsouled <rowe@[E  2008-05-17 12:36:40 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-17 18:53:45 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-17 15:03:29 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-17 19:23:06 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-17 22:12:26 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-18 06:09:03 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-18 06:25:10 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-18 09:30:39 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-18 11:08:13 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-18 09:32:34 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-18 11:13:46 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
tsuki190 <tsuki190@[EM  2008-05-18 09:36:33 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-18 14:13:27 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-18 15:11:55 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
Foucaultian <drfostern  2008-05-18 12:35:16 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-18 17:24:22 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-18 17:02:47 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-18 18:58:14 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-18 17:13:59 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-18 17:10:51 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-18 19:07:39 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-18 17:23:21 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-18 19:55:44 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
Foucaultian <drfostern  2008-05-18 15:00:24 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-18 21:43:34 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-19 08:42:44 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-18 16:57:26 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-18 22:30:52 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Kent Johnson"   2008-05-19 08:22:14 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
Foucaultian <drfostern  2008-05-18 20:40:17 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-18 22:42:44 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-18 22:48:12 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
Foucaultian <drfostern  2008-05-19 08:00:27 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
Foucaultian <drfostern  2008-05-19 08:19:49 
Re: Baha'i Exclusivism for REAL
"Susan Maneck"   2008-05-19 11:22:52 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Mon Sep 8 11:25:33 CDT 2008.