Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Religion > Islam in Australia > Re: MORE Quran ...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 1 of 1 Topic 28036 of 29014
Post > Topic >>

Re: MORE Quran contradictions .... . . . . . .........

by Ramabriga <Ramabriga@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > May 9, 2008 at 01:40 PM

Arash Gharahmadani wrote:
> Islam is ****! wrote:
>>   Sura 26: 192 It (the Qur'an) is indeed a revelation from the Lord of 
>> the
>> Worlds,
>>   193 with it came down the spirit of truth
>>   194 Upon your heart so that you may be one of the warners
>>   195 in clear Arabic speech
>>   196 and indeed IT (the Qur'an) is in the writings of the earlier
>> (prophets).
>> A Muslim's comment (on the Islamic newsgroup)was: "YES! The Qur'an is
IN
>> them and they are complete IN the Qur'an. What does this tell you? 
>> They are
>> identical!"
>>
>> Now, I am not sure if how many Muslims hold to this opinion, but here
are
>> nevertheless two powerful self-contradictions in the verses 195-196.
>>
>> One im****tant reason for the revelation of the Qur'an in Arabic is 
>> that the
>> earlier books were NOT in Arabic and therefore the Arabs could not
>> understand them. Now even if the Qur'an and the earlier books are not
>> identical [apart from translation in a different language] verse 196
does
>> say that the Qur'an is contained in the earlier books.
>>
>> Now we have the choice between two different lies in God's revelations.
>> Either, because of verse 196, the verse "in clear Arabic speech" is
>> contained in the earlier revelations. This is a lie, because they are 
>> not in
>> Arabic.Therefore it cannot be in the earlier revelation. But then 
>> verse 196
>> becomes a lie in the Qur'an.
>>
>> Maybe this situation can be saved by regarding "in clear Arabic 
>> speech" to
>> be only belonging to "so that you (Muhammad) may be one of the 
>> warners" and
>> NOT refering to the Qur'an (it) in verse 192. But then, what were the
>> warnings of Muhammad in Arabic? The verses of the Qur'an...
>>
>> But there are more such verses, for example 16:103 also claims that 
>> "this is
>> Arabic pure and clear" which refers to the Qur'an without doubt.
>>
>> But verse 196 is a jewel of contradiction just within itself. How many
>> "earlier writings" were there? Finitely many or infinitely many? Have
you
>> ever written a computer program that went into an infinite loop? Well, 
>> you
>> have before your very eyes a recursion without a condition for 
>> termination.
>> And you are not allowed to change the program. Talk about the worst
>> nightmare imaginable for a computer programmer.
>>
>> Verse 196 is part of the Qur'an, and hence by its very statement also 
>> part
>> of the earlier writings. Let say, it is in earlier writing A. Now, by
the
>> very same reason, there has to be an earlier writing B, containing this
>> verse, and earlier writing C containing this verse, and .... without 
>> end and
>> you need infinitely many earlier writings because you otherwise end up
in
>> the lie of verse 196 claiming to be contained in a non-existing earlier
>> writing.
>>
>> But infinitely many writings are physically impossible. Isn't that a
most
>> interesting contradiction / error / problem in just one verse?
>>
>> But take heart, some of the best and most intelligent people have
written
>> programs with such errors. It is no shame for Muhammad to overlook 
>> that bug.
>> The problem is not the bug, but that he decreed that nobody is allowed
to
>> correct the bugs. And since no provision was made to update and 
>> maintain the
>> program, it sadly has to be abandoned. Nobody wants to be stuck in an
>> infinite loop without being allowed to stop the program.
>>
>> Verse 196 is indeed producing numerous problems. There are many things
in
>> the Qur'an which become utter non-sense if you imagine them to be in
the
>> Torah or the Gospel. The consequence would be that God gives foolish
>> revelations and talks gibberish. This is obviously not true, so that 
>> we have
>> to reject verse 196 as illogical.
>>
>>
>>
>>
> 
> 
> In Google Groups, search for "Arash", then click on "profile" and you'll

> get the below response:
> 
> Profile
> 
> This account has been banned because it violated the Google Groups Terms

> Of Use.
> 
> Enter an email address to look up the profile for an author:
> 
> 
> 
> BWHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
> 
> 
> HOW TO BECOME A ****SKIN MOSLEM - this is how: **** goats, molest 
> children, wear a beekeepers outfit all the time, never shower or bath, 
> beat your wives, learn terrorist activities at a maddrassa, wipe your 
> ass with stones, sell the donkey you ****ed to a nearby village, marry a

> nine year-old , send your child off to an indoctrination camp, practice 
> thighing with little kids, ............  Practice all those and you too 
> could become a prophet !!
> 
HOW TO BECOME A ****SKIN  MOSLEM - this is how: **** goats, **** your 
mother (nikomak), molest children, wear a beekeepers outfit all the 
time, never shower or bath, beat your wives, learn terrorist activities 
at a maddrassa, wipe your ass with stones, sell the donkey you ****ed to 
a nearby village, marry a nine year-old , send your child off to an 
indoctrination camp, practice thighing with little kids, ............ 
Practice all those and you too could become a prophet !!


Elif air ab tizak mohammad !!!!

info@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
  or apache@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 or 
politicsIranian@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Posted from http://www.teranews.com
**

-- 

moslem cartoon character mohammad and his bumchum allaah were child 
molesting goat ****ers and nikomaks


                                _
                              /'_/)
                            ,/_  /
                           /    /
                     /'_'/'   '/'__'7,
                  /'/    /    /    /" /_\
                 ('(    ' /'   ')
                  \      /
                   '\'              _.7'
                     \             (
                       \            \

Up your ass mohammad  - Elif air ab tizak!!!

info@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
  or apache@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 or 
politicsIranian@[EMAIL PROTECTED]

 




 1 Posts in Topic:
Re: MORE Quran contradictions .... . . . . . ..
Ramabriga <Ramabriga@[  2008-05-09 13:40:48 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan13V112 Fri Jul 25 15:24:33 CDT 2008.