Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Religion > Presbyterian > Re: Parable of ...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 8 of 14 Topic 5688 of 5848
Post > Topic >>

Re: Parable of the Ten Virigins

by "Reuben Hick" <outerdarkness@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Apr 2, 2008 at 11:02 PM

"Semper LibčrŽ ." <.nopolicestates???!?~Hj77@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in 
message news:czXIj.14029$9X3.9336@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> "Reuben Hick" <outerdarkness@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message
> news:mIWIj.21150$xq2.18046@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>> "Semper LibčrŽ ." <.nopolicestates???!?~Hj77@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in
>> message news:_bfIj.11205$pb5.3069@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>> >
>> > "Reuben Hick" <outerdarkness@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message
>> > news:9BTHj.23018$0o7.13220@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>> >> Let me first admit that what I propose here I could not find in over
> two
>> >> dozen commentaries by theologians over the spread of many centuries.

>> >> I
>> > have
>> >> listened to many sermons on the topic, and I have been to many
groups
> who
>> >> talked about this parable.    What I have found is that every
> commentator
>> >> either ignores the parable, dismisses most of the symbolic
references,
> or
>> >> makes symbolic references that are fully unqualified:  ie.  Calling 
>> >> the
>> >> virgins "Christians" or "believers",  or calling the oil the Holy
> Spirit.
>> >> None of this is substantiated, and even the commentators note that 
>> >> this
>> > can't
>> >> be taken too far.
>> >
>> > You got all this from the parable of the ten virgins? My hats off to 
>> > ya,
>> > but
>> > I think you missed the point.
>> >
>> > The parable is about the imminence of Yeshua's return.
>>
>> "Imminence" = over 1970 years and still counting...
>
> Which by God's watch is a little less than two days....

So what is your point?

First rule of clear communication: put things in terms your intended 
audience understands.  If everyone you speak to thinks Imminence means 
something is about to occur soon relative to their own lifetime, then the 
message will be lost if you meant many generations afterwards.

Besides I don't see imminence taught in the parable.  I do see "you don't 
know when" and I do see that the bridegroom came rather late 
(traditionally 
the bridegroom comes in shortly after sunset).   The midnight timing is a 
rabbinical teaching and corresponds to the time of the Exodus - something 
that is relevant to the audience.

I did find a message by the late S Lewis Johnson, professor at Dallas 
Theological Seminary.  I knew him as a classical pre-mill rather than
Dispy. 
I'm amil, so I wasn't surprised when he brought up the "and the bride"
lost 
words that were found in the earlier manuscripts.  Not that it changes 
anything from an amil/post-mil  perspective.

http://www.believerschapeldallas.org/a/Johnson/slj-51_Matthew/083_SLJ_51_32K.m3u

He eisegetes a pre-mill eschatology into it.  He also differs in that he 
says the oil is the Paraclete.   I struggle with that association since 
"blessings" has a much richer support in the OT, and the Paraclete wasn't 
revealed fully until Pentacost.

But at least I found someone who goes with the prophetic angle.




 14 Posts in Topic:
Parable of the Ten Virigins
"Reuben Hick" &  2008-03-30 21:27:34 
Re: Parable of the Ten Virigins
PrivateParty <rdbyrnef  2008-03-31 14:12:00 
Re: Parable of the Ten Virigins
"vernon O" <  2008-03-31 17:18:36 
Re: Parable of the Ten Virigins
"Reuben Hick" &  2008-04-02 23:08:08 
Re: Parable of the Ten Virigins
"Semper LibčrŽ   2008-04-01 00:19:06 
Re: Parable of the Ten Virigins
"Reuben Hick" &  2008-04-03 01:49:06 
Re: Parable of the Ten Virigins
"Semper LibčrŽ   2008-04-03 02:47:36 
Re: Parable of the Ten Virigins
"Reuben Hick" &  2008-04-02 23:02:56 
Re: Parable of the Ten Virigins
"Reuben Hick" &  2008-04-02 23:28:17 
Re: Parable of the Ten Virigins
"Fred A Stover"  2008-04-03 02:55:32 
Private Message
   2008-04-03 00:38:57 
Private Message
   2008-04-01 10:12:11 
Private Message
   2008-04-02 23:32:11 
Private Message
   2008-04-03 14:05:11 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan13V112 Fri Jul 4 16:21:55 CDT 2008.